仪器信息网APP
选仪器、听讲座、看资讯

急问我这样的审稿意见是大修好,还是重新找个杂志投好呢?!!!

  • li8888lili8888
    2012/09/14
  • 私聊

论文写作和投稿

  • Your manuscript # APP-2012-07-2511 entitled "XXX" which you submitted to the Journal of Applied Polymer Science, has been reviewed. While the referees find your work of some potential interest, they have raised concerns that are sufficiently important that they preclude publication of the work in the Journal of Applied Polymer Science, at least in its present form.

    In particular, we would like you to discuss the novelty and the advance in this work over a published manuscript: J. Phys. Chem. C, 2011, 115 (22), pp 11282–11292. This work was not cited in your submission.

    Should further research work allow you to address exhaustively these criticisms we would be happy to look at a revised manuscript (unless something similar has by then been accepted at our journal or appeared elsewhere).

    The comments from reviewers are included at the bottom of this letter.

    Please note that resubmitting your manuscript does not guarantee eventual acceptance, and that your resubmission will be subject to re-review by the reviewers before a decision is rendered.

    May I take this opportunity to thank you for considering our Journal for the publication of your work. We hope that you will consider resubmitting your manuscript to the Journal.
  • 该帖子已被版主-省部重点实验室加2积分,加2经验;加分理由:常来论文写作与投稿 交流学习(⊙o⊙)哦
    +关注 私聊
  • gbluo324

    第1楼2012/09/14

    这个意见不是很难改啊,只需要把审稿人列的那篇文章与你的工作进行比较,突出你的工作的创新和优势。注意审稿人可能就是那篇文章的通讯作者,所以要慎重修改,要委婉的指出别人存在的问题,不然很容易拒稿。
    编辑给了机会,要好好修改。这个意见相当于大修,需要重新投稿,还可能给原来审稿人再审。

0
  • 该帖子已被版主-省部重点实验室加3积分,加2经验;加分理由:常来论文写作与投稿 交流学习(⊙o⊙)哦
    +关注 私聊
  • gbluo324

    第2楼2012/09/14

    当然,如果觉得不好修改,可以改投其他杂志,但是出于礼貌,应该给这个杂志写封信感谢一下,并解释为什么不修改的原因。

0
    +关注 私聊
  • li8888lili8888

    第3楼2012/09/14

    恩,我也觉得,你说的很有道理!!!

    gbluo324(gbluo324) 发表:当然,如果觉得不好修改,可以改投其他杂志,但是出于礼貌,应该给这个杂志写封信感谢一下,并解释为什么不修改的原因。

0
    +关注 私聊
  • 水源守护者

    第4楼2012/09/29

    同意楼上的,这样方便下次再投该刊物

0
猜你喜欢最新推荐热门推荐更多推荐
举报帖子

执行举报

点赞用户
好友列表
加载中...
正在为您切换请稍后...